Imagining Argentina 2003

imdb-logo 6.1 / 10

Imagining Argentina

Set during the unsettling disappearances in Buenos Aires during the dictatorship of the 1970s, the film involves theater director Carlos Rueda and his wife Cecilia. Shortly after Cecilia writes an editorial commentary questioning the mysterious abductions, she is herself abducted and taken into police custody.

Set during the unsettling disappearances in Buenos Aires during the dictatorship of the 1970s, the film involves theater director Carlos Rueda and his wife Cecilia. Shortly after Cecilia writes an editorial commentary questioning the mysterious abductions, she is herself abducted and taken into police custody.

Videos & Photos

All 0 Videos & 6 Photos

... Carlos Rueda

... Cecilia Rueda

... Teresa Rueda

... Esme Palomares

... Silvio Ayala

... Eurydice

User reviews

See All 1 Reviews

13 Sep 2022 by tmdb28039023

Imagining Argentina could only be imagined by a perversely ignorant mind. Since its director/screenwriter is Christopher Hampton, who before and after has adapted the screenplays of Dangerous Liaisons, Mary Reilly, The Quiet American, and The Father, I can only blame Lawrence Thornton, whose novel inspired (though perhaps a better word would be instigated) this vile piece of crap. The film takes place in 1977, in an Argentina where everyone speaks English with a wide range of Hispanic and Latin American accents, none of which sound remotely Argentinian. The exception is Emma Thompson, who uses her natural British accent even though her character's name is Cecilia Rueda. She is a dissident journalist in Buenos Aires; after publishing an article denouncing the forced disappearance of students protesting bus fares, Cecilia is kidnapped by the secret police. Faced with the indifference, and almost certain complicity, of the authorities, her husband Carlos (Antonio Banderas) puts up posters with Cecilia's photo, but I doubt that these are of any use, considering that the information on them is printed in Spanish and here everyone, as I just noted, speaks English. This linguistic dissonance, however, is not the most outrageous aspect the movie. Oh no; that dubious honor is reserved for the fact, and I swear I'm not making this up, that Carlos happens to be psychic. Really. Carlos is producing a play for a youth theater troupe, and one fine day, completely out of the blue, he tells one of the actors that his father, who was also kidnapped, will be released later that night. “It was as if I was remembering the future,” he explains to his friend and colleague Silvio (Rubén Blades, who that same year appeared in Once Upon a Time in Mexico; who would have imagined that the latter would be the more realistic of the two). The whole thing is like a cross between Tell Me How I Die and the Saturday Night Live episode where Chris Walken is a "trivial psychic," except that there’s nothing trivial about state terrorism in Argentina in the 1970s and 1980s. Carlos's prediction comes true, which could very well have been a coincidence; however, he never questions his new powers and soon summons the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo to reveal the fate of their loved ones. All of this is extremely insensitive, offensive, and disrespectful. Not only does it minimize an enormous tragedy, but on top of that, whether deliberately or not, effectively calls it into question. Let's say that Johnny Moviegoer does not know the full extent of the atrocities committed during the last dictatorship in Argentina, but he is fully aware that in real life no one can "remember the future"; now, if the movie indiscriminately exaggerates the latter, who could blame Johnny for assuming that the former is likewise pure hyperbole? As it is, the graphic scenes of rape and torture presented in the film are gratuitous because they do not take place in a medium that bears any resemblance to the real world. Films like Night of the Pencils and The Official Story are vastly superior not only because they were written in Spanish and directed and acted by Argentines, but above all because they take their material very seriously. Imagining Argentina is, and this is the lesser of its evils, unnecessary, but since they felt compelled to do it, why not change Carlos from a real psychic to a charlatan who slowly changes his attitude as he becomes more familiar with the stories of the people he’s scamming? That way it wouldn’t be the filmmakers the ones who end up coming across as swindlers.

Release Date:

Sep 13, 2003 (Spain,United Kingdom,United States)

Run Time:

1hr 47`

MMPA Rating:

Original Language:

English

Production Countries:

Spain,United Kingdom,United States

Status:

Released

Related Movies To

Imagining Argentina

Write Review

Found 1 reviews in total

13 Sep 2022 by tmdb28039023

Imagining Argentina could only be imagined by a perversely ignorant mind. Since its director/screenwriter is Christopher Hampton, who before and after has adapted the screenplays of Dangerous Liaisons, Mary Reilly, The Quiet American, and The Father, I can only blame Lawrence Thornton, whose novel inspired (though perhaps a better word would be instigated) this vile piece of crap. The film takes place in 1977, in an Argentina where everyone speaks English with a wide range of Hispanic and Latin American accents, none of which sound remotely Argentinian. The exception is Emma Thompson, who uses her natural British accent even though her character's name is Cecilia Rueda. She is a dissident journalist in Buenos Aires; after publishing an article denouncing the forced disappearance of students protesting bus fares, Cecilia is kidnapped by the secret police. Faced with the indifference, and almost certain complicity, of the authorities, her husband Carlos (Antonio Banderas) puts up posters with Cecilia's photo, but I doubt that these are of any use, considering that the information on them is printed in Spanish and here everyone, as I just noted, speaks English. This linguistic dissonance, however, is not the most outrageous aspect the movie. Oh no; that dubious honor is reserved for the fact, and I swear I'm not making this up, that Carlos happens to be psychic. Really. Carlos is producing a play for a youth theater troupe, and one fine day, completely out of the blue, he tells one of the actors that his father, who was also kidnapped, will be released later that night. “It was as if I was remembering the future,” he explains to his friend and colleague Silvio (Rubén Blades, who that same year appeared in Once Upon a Time in Mexico; who would have imagined that the latter would be the more realistic of the two). The whole thing is like a cross between Tell Me How I Die and the Saturday Night Live episode where Chris Walken is a "trivial psychic," except that there’s nothing trivial about state terrorism in Argentina in the 1970s and 1980s. Carlos's prediction comes true, which could very well have been a coincidence; however, he never questions his new powers and soon summons the Mothers of Plaza de Mayo to reveal the fate of their loved ones. All of this is extremely insensitive, offensive, and disrespectful. Not only does it minimize an enormous tragedy, but on top of that, whether deliberately or not, effectively calls it into question. Let's say that Johnny Moviegoer does not know the full extent of the atrocities committed during the last dictatorship in Argentina, but he is fully aware that in real life no one can "remember the future"; now, if the movie indiscriminately exaggerates the latter, who could blame Johnny for assuming that the former is likewise pure hyperbole? As it is, the graphic scenes of rape and torture presented in the film are gratuitous because they do not take place in a medium that bears any resemblance to the real world. Films like Night of the Pencils and The Official Story are vastly superior not only because they were written in Spanish and directed and acted by Argentines, but above all because they take their material very seriously. Imagining Argentina is, and this is the lesser of its evils, unnecessary, but since they felt compelled to do it, why not change Carlos from a real psychic to a charlatan who slowly changes his attitude as he becomes more familiar with the stories of the people he’s scamming? That way it wouldn’t be the filmmakers the ones who end up coming across as swindlers.

Cast & Crew of

Imagining Argentina

Directors & Credit Writers

Cast

... Carlos Rueda

... Cecilia Rueda

... Teresa Rueda

... Esme Palomares

... Silvio Ayala

... Eurydice

... Orfeo / Enrico

... Pedro Augustín

... Policeman 1

... Policeman 2

... Rubén Mendoza

... Concepta Madrid

... Octavio Marquez's Grandmother

... Hannah Masson

... Victor Madrid

... Julia Obregon's Mother

... Amos Sternberg

... Sara Sternberg

Produced By

... Co-executive Producer

... Co-producer

... Producer

Videos & Photos of

Imagining Argentina

Photos ( 6 )

Related Movies To

Imagining Argentina

Found 12 Movies in total

poster-Kraven the Hunter
Kraven the Hunter (2024)

0 /10

Kraven Kravinoff's complex relationship with his ruthless gangster father, Nikolai, starts him down a path of vengeance with brutal consequences, motivating him to become not only the greatest hunter in the world, but also one of its most feared.

Run Time: 2hr 7` . MMPA: R . Release: 11 Dec 2024

Director: Dani Watson , Carley Armstrong , J.C. Chandor

Producer: Chloe Gonzalez , Nicola Chisholm , Matt Tolmach

Stars: Aaron Taylor-Johnson , Russell Crowe , Ariana DeBose , Fred Hechinger , Alessandro Nivola , Christopher Abbott

poster-Alarum
Alarum (2025)

0 /10

Two married spies caught in the crosshairs of an international intelligence network will stop at nothing to obtain a critical asset. Joe and Lara are agents living off the grid whose quiet retreat at a winter resort is blown to shreds when members of the old guard suspect the two may have joined an elite team of rogue spies, known as Alarum.

Run Time: 1hr 35` . MMPA: R . Release: 16 Jan 2025

Director: Michael Polish

Producer: Bryan Riley , Steven Small , Justin Routt

Stars: Sylvester Stallone , Scott Eastwood , La Monde Byrd , Willa Fitzgerald , Mike Colter , Beau Bommarito

poster-Sniper: The Last Stand
Sniper: The Last Stand (2025)

0 /10

To stop an arms dealer from unleashing a deadly superweapon, Ace sniper Brandon Beckett and Agent Zero are deployed to Costa Verde to lead a group of elite soldiers against an unrelenting militia. Taking an untested sniper under his wing, Beckett faces his newest challenge: giving orders instead of receiving them. With both time and ammo running low in a race to save humanity, the team must overcome all odds just to survive.

Run Time: 1hr 39` . MMPA: R . Release: 21 Jan 2025

Director: Pierre Bezuidenhout , Killian April , Liezl Geldenhuys

Producer: Bonnie Lee Bouman , Rafeeq Yusuf , Sari Tiersky

Stars: Chad Michael Collins , Ryan Robbins , Manuel Rodriguez-Saenz , Arnold Vosloo , Sharon Taylor , Scott George

poster-Werewolves
Werewolves (2024)

0 /10

A year after a supermoon’s light activated a dormant gene, transforming humans into bloodthirsty werewolves and causing nearly a billion deaths, the nightmare resurfaces as the supermoon rises again. Two scientists attempt to stop the mutation but fail and must now struggle to reach one of their family homes.

Run Time: 1hr 34` . MMPA: R . Release: 04 Dec 2024

Director: Steven C. Miller

Producer: Luis R. Estrella-Rivera , Jimmy Cummings , Michelle Lewitt

Stars: Frank Grillo , Katrina Law , Ilfenesh Hadera , Sam Daly , James Kyson , Lou Diamond Phillips

poster-Gladiator II
Gladiator II (2024)

0 /10

Years after witnessing the death of the revered hero Maximus at the hands of his uncle, Lucius is forced to enter the Colosseum after his home is conquered by the tyrannical Emperors who now lead Rome with an iron fist. With rage in his heart and the future of the Empire at stake, Lucius must look to his past to find strength and honor to return the glory of Rome to its people.

Run Time: 2hr 28` . MMPA: R / PG-13 . Release: 05 Nov 2024

Director: Conor Flannery , Vanluke Watson , Oana Ene

Producer: Aidan Elliott , Darren Chesney , Yann Mari Faget

Stars: Paul Mescal , Fred Hechinger , Denzel Washington , Connie Nielsen , Joseph Quinn , Pedro Pascal

poster-Anora
Anora (2024)

0 /10

A young sex worker from Brooklyn gets her chance at a Cinderella story when she meets and impulsively marries the son of an oligarch. Once the news reaches Russia, her fairytale is threatened as his parents set out to get the marriage annulled.

Run Time: 2hr 19` . MMPA: R . Release: 14 Oct 2024

Director: Sofía Blanco , Liza Mann , Sean Baker

Producer: Milan Popelka , Ross Brodar , Glen Basner

Stars: Ivy Wolk , Mark Eydelstein , Mikey Madison , Yuriy Borisov , Karren Karagulian , Vache Tovmasyan

poster-Den of Thieves 2: Pantera
Den of Thieves 2: Pantera (2025)

0 /10

Big Nick is back on the hunt in Europe and closing in on Donnie, who is embroiled in the treacherous and unpredictable world of diamond thieves and the infamous Panther mafia, as they plot a massive heist of the world's largest diamond exchange.

Run Time: 2hr 24` . MMPA: R . Release: 08 Jan 2025

Director: Christian Gudegast

Producer: Swen Temmel , Alan Siegel , Tucker Tooley

Stars: Gerard Butler , O'Shea Jackson Jr. , Meadow Williams , Jordan Bridges , Swen Temmel , Michael Bisping

poster-Elevation
Elevation (2024)

0 /10

A single father and two women venture from the safety of their homes to face monstrous creatures to save the life of a young boy.

Run Time: 1hr 31` . MMPA: R . Release: 07 Nov 2024

Director: George Nolfi

Producer: Alex Black , Carl Beyer , Jason Spire

Stars: Anthony Mackie , Morena Baccarin , Maddie Hasson , Danny Boyd Jr. , Rachel Nicks , Shauna Earp

poster-Babygirl
Babygirl (2024)

0 /10

A high-powered CEO puts her career and family on the line when she begins a torrid affair with her much younger intern.

Run Time: 1hr 55` . MMPA: R . Release: 25 Dec 2024

Director: Jimmy Rosario , Christo Morse , Halina Reijn

Producer: Jonathan Olson , Audrey Cicerello , Avy Kaufman

Stars: Nicole Kidman , Harris Dickinson , Jude Law , Antonio Banderas , Sophie Wilde , Jean Reno

poster-Aftermath
Aftermath (2024)

0 /10

A returning war veteran, stricken with PTSD, gets trapped with his teenage sister on Boston's Tobin Memorial Bridge when a heavily armed group of ex-military revolutionaries take everyone hostage.

Run Time: 1hr 35` . MMPA: R . Release: 27 Sep 2024

Director: Patrick Lussier

Producer: Jonathan Deckter , Nancy Nayor , Brett Duffy

Stars: Mason Gooding , Dylan Sprouse , Dichen Lachman , Megan Stott , Kevin Chapman , Will Lyman

poster-Wicked
Wicked (2024)

0 /10

In the land of Oz, ostracized and misunderstood green-skinned Elphaba is forced to share a room with the popular aristocrat Glinda at Shiz University, and the two's unlikely friendship is tested as they begin to fulfill their respective destinies as Glinda the Good and the Wicked Witch of the West.

Run Time: 2hr 42` . MMPA: PG . Release: 20 Nov 2024

Director: Jon M. Chu , Lisa Vick

Producer: Dana Gaier , Carly Schoepflin , Jared LeBoff

Stars: Cynthia Erivo , Ariana Grande , Jonathan Bailey , Jeff Goldblum , Michelle Yeoh , Ethan Slater

poster-Carry-On
Carry-On (2024)

0 /10

An airport security officer races to outsmart a mysterious traveler forcing him to let a dangerous item slip onto a Christmas Eve flight.

Run Time: 2hr . MMPA: PG-13 . Release: 05 Dec 2024

Director: Josh Stephenson , Kevin O'Neill , Benita Allen

Producer: Marisol Roncali , Scout Winn-Borges , Lee Pierce

Stars: Taron Egerton , Jason Bateman , Sofia Carson , Dean Norris , Danielle Deadwyler , Theo Rossi